Putting the Social in Social Media
December 6th, 2008Yesterday my Twitter list was full discussion with Jack Ward (Sonic Society) about the good vs bad of online relationships. I am a staunch advocate for the idea that you can become intimate, caring and close friends with someone you only communicate through the medium of the internet with. Jack, on the other hand, doesn’t believe that’s healthy or 100% true.
It seems I’ve been defending my social skills my whole life.
Social Skills
I was homeschooled from kindergarten to high school and the number one whine I’ve heard (and had to defend against) but what about her social development?
I never suffered a social problem in my life. I had friends my own age, friends who were old and friends who were much younger. I had a weekly youth group I went to, plus (with my dad being a pastor) I was always around the folks from our church and we had fellowships of other churches where I did kids olympics and Bible quizzing with.
So I’m a huge advocate of bashing the idea that homeschool kids can’t have socialization.
Now that I’m an adult, I have another advocacy to lead the charge again. This time I’m a huge advocate for bashing the idea that people online can’t have meaningful socialization.
Background
Let’s get a few things clear. I’m 27.
I started online when I was 16. It was the early days with AOL. We had a 14K modem dial-up and took a book a long with me while I waited for AOL to start and pages to load.
But I was hooked.
I had been a Sherlockian since age 9, and instantly found a group of Sherlockians online. Shortly after that I launched an email newsletter (one of the first of it’s kind) with news and updates about Sherlock Holmes from around the world. By the end of my senior year I had over 500 subscribers.
I also discovered bulletin boards (where I met a bunch of people, one of whom pretened to be a cat) and an amazing Sherlockian, Les Klinger (who has since gone on to author the most recent annotated Sherlock Holmes series). Shortly after I started email corresponding Les, I wanted to meet him. He lived in West Hollywood, I was in East Los Angeles. With my parents I went to his house and had the most amazing afternoon talking Sherlock Holmes).
I was 17, he was in his late 40’s. We’ve corresponded several time since then but drifted apart. As with most of my face-to-face friends from that time.
Then I hit college. Between my best friend and I we knew everyone on campus. We were in the middle of most events and doing media and technology. We had a T1 cable line in our dorm rooms, I had a new computer my parents bought me and I become even more social in real life and onine. I even would IM my roommate while we were working on papers in the same room.
During this time I became a part of a forum for Kevin Max (a musician formerly with the Christian mega-group dcTalk). I made friends through there and eventually all of us wanted to meet in real life. Kevin had a concert in Nashville my senior year of college and a bunch of people from the forums were going – and I wanted to go to. So I did, I met about 20 people I had been ‘online’ friends with for about a year and a half. And we hit it off like we’d known each other face to face. One of them was a teenage girl I had ‘adopted’ as a little sister. She had been struggling with various forms of depression (as a lot of teenagers do) which really boiled down to her self-worth. When we met it for the first time she gave me the tightest hug you’d ever have and she was glued to me the rest of the night.
I had made a difference in her life. Only through text. Her stepdad (who had came with her) thanked me over and over again for the changes he had seen because I told her how much she meant and the value she had as a person. Because I was there and cared.
Would it have been nice to be able to hug her when she was sad? Of course. Would it have been nice to take her out for ice cream as a reward for working so hard in school? Yes! But she was 2,000 miles away.
And yet, I touched her life. And she touched mine.
Shortly after that I met my friend Nichole – we’ve been super close for over 5 years now. We’ve had our ups and down like any friendship, but we’re two people who know each other inside out. In fact, yesterday when I was lost I called her up to figure out where I needed to go!
I’m not saying that to brag. Honestly it still boggles my mind the difference you can make in someone’s life without ever meeting them.
When my sister came to live with me awhile back, it took all the money I had to fly her up (it’s a long involved story). My ‘online’ friends pitched in money to help pay for our groceries and her birthday presents. People who didn’t even know her and people I never met. Some people I still haven’t met.
When I moved into my latest apartment online friends bought me housewarming gifts! I’ve gotten birthday and Christmas cards from around the world because of online friends.
Now.
Fast forward to 2007, when I first started friendships with two of my current best friends – Emma and Kim. Kim, Emma and I bonded over Buffy the Vampire Slayer. That shared passion, enthusasm and love was only the catalyst for our friendship. Now we talk and share everything about our lives (down to the nitty gritty girl stuff that I won’t bore you with on this blog). I want Kim to be my maid of honor if I get married, and I want Emma to be one of my bridesmaids – we’re that close. I’ve even said that Emma and I are going to get a house when we’re older, have cats and write. And that would be a perfect life in my eyes. I have Kim and Emma in my heart and carry around thoughts of them wherever I go. Even when I’m shopping I’ll stop and think, “this would be perfect for Emma,” or “Kim and I just talked about this.”
I even factored in Emma into my decisions about finding an apartment because I knew she’d be visiting for a month (after I moved in). And I spent money on a futon, so she’d have a place to sleep. For months my parents and I discussed Emma’s visit and “Emma’s bed” and Emma’s food and Emma’s schedule.
And I hadn’t met Emma in real life yet.
The moment she stepped into the airport I knew she was my Emma (and now I’m being a ridiculous girl and tearing up). We bonded instantly and I fell in a very natural friendship with her.
Emma lives in England, there’s no way we could hang out every day (unless you invent me a transporter, which I’d be very happy for). Yet, Emma’s a closer friend than anyone (outside my family) who lives near me.
I’ve had a rocky life. Not as bad as some people I know, but there have been many bad days. And I’ve had online friends that I’ve had to call and sob with. And just knowing they cared was a hug enough for me. When they said it – I really did feel it. Why? Because of the power of communication. Of words.
I currently work online (as my job) and I do a lot of podcasting and some freelance work – so the computer is on my lap at least 10 hours a day. My friends and co-workers are there with me during the day (in IM, on Skype, etc). Our relationships blossom because they are -right there- when things happen.
What’s the Big Idea?
Have I kept all of my online friends for life? No, but I haven’t kept all my highschool friends or college friends or work friends.
Are they somehow ‘less’ than my other friends? No, not in their meaning and significance to me.
Online Relationships are Inauthentic?
Could there be online relationships that are shams? Yep, I’ve even been subjected to men pretending to be women. Or people pretending to be someone they’re not. The availability of ruining someone’s trust is rampent. Especially if you stick to places like chat rooms, Second Life, World of Warcraft, etc.
Yet, the people that have lied to me in the past are a small percentage and usually are easily found out. Lying is an art form and takes a lot of energy – even if it’s just online.
But this isn’t just an online phenomon.
Consider the amount of people who can have an affair (successfully) for years. Or the amount of con men. Or the people who have faked diplomas, passports, etc. The amount of people who have reinvented themselves or cops who can go undercover and be someone else. Human beings are the same – no matter how you meet them. Part of my job takes me to tech business cocktail parties – sad to say the amount of ‘fake’ people there is astounding.
What’s a relationship anyways?
According to Wikipedia, “An interpersonal relationship is a relatively long-term association between two or more people. This association may be based on emotions like love and liking, regular business interactions, or some other type of social commitment. Interpersonal relationships take place in a great variety of contexts, such as family, friends, marriage, acquaintances, work, clubs, neighborhoods, and churches.”
As you can see what constitutes a releationship is interactions, associations, social commitment. Nothing really about physical location. Is it easier with someone closer to you? Possibly. I’ve had a lot of friends I’ve drifted away from who were on the same floor as me at college. I’ve also moved away from other people (like all my college friends) and kept touch. The key to any relationship is two-way communication that continues. If that dies, then so dies the friendship.
All of these aspects of relationship I have for my friends like WorldofHiglet, Beth in Australia, Heidi, Clay, Brian, Melia, Nutty (even though I can’t pronounce her name), the cast and crew of Buffy Between the Lines, etc. As I’ve grown to know them they’ve shared things about themselves, about their lives, about their fears, their bad days, their good days and everything in between. I count them all as friends. People who care about me, who interact with me, and people who I care about. My close online friends I’ve seen them in a multitide of situations and emotions. There’s something that trescends words on a page when you’re talking to a friend.
The Bottom Line
Is physical connections important? Yes, of course. Especially for someone like me. I crave physical touch and sensation. I’ve found I sleep better with a faux fur blanket because of the sensation stimulus it gives me.
Can someone isolate themselves online? Yes, if you’re neglecting important obligations and personal relationships (i.e. if you’ve made your wife a ‘World of Warcraft Widow’) then something is wrong. But this can also happen in real life (i.e. if your wife is now a ‘golf widow’).
Can people violate your trust online? Yes, of course. But they can do it off-line as well.
If I could I would visit all my friends in person whenever I could. But of course they’re spread out all over the world and that’s impossible. But they’re still as important as the people I see in person, if not more important.
After all, at the end of the day – a friend is a friend. No matter how small.

Yesterday, there was an interesting conversation that took place on Twitter. While I’m still waiting to hear the full story (Twitter is still rather limited in understanding scope, depth and breadth of conversations), I figured it had inspired me enough to write about my recent experiences with knowing and being a micro-celebrity*.